An introvert would be placed in front of a tough choice, as introverted guys enjoy both, but, predictably, most would choose to get rid of music and keep their books - they spend way too much time with them to be comfortable with getting rid of them.If this was a regular conversation topic list, and not a funny "would you rather" question list, this would be formed as a "what would you like to change about yourself" question.Sadness or anger, it's a tough choice, and will give you a glimpse into what has the guy you're speaking with experienced more often. I know I'd not go for it, if I was forced to pick between the two, even if the price for it would be to always lie.
It's also a question you can be asking yourself - having one wish fulfilled immediately sounds like plenty of fun, but three wishes in 10 years? It's a matter of discipline and logic, but those two factors aren't the ones prevailing all the time.
While it looks like this question is simplistic and light-hearted one, it still does reveal a bit about someone's character traits.
Super strength as a power is one that heroes chose, a power to win fights and to be able to protect others. However, invisibility is a much more nefarious choice, it's a choice of guys that would prefer being subtle and taking courses that may seem cowardly, but are actually more thought-out.
Out of all "would you rather" questions to ask a guy, this one is most difficult to pick an answer to. Never speaking again does pose a huge problem, but it's one you could, in theory, work around, although it would affect your quality of communication. If the guy you are posing this question to is at least a bit dirty-minded, he will shy away from this choice immediately.
Note that that is not necessarily a bad thing - think of all the things that go through your mind during a conversation, would you like to have those out in the open?
This is a pretty fun "dynamic vs static" or "extrovert vs introvert" question.
An extrovert person would most likely make a choice of getting rid of books from his life - after all, you don't get too much time to read when you're on the move and surrounded by people all the time.
If you need some fun would you rather questions to ask a guy you like, here's a list you can use, with questions that every guy has to at least stop and think about for a second.
The questions are light-hearted at first glance, but can show what's hiding beneath the surface and reveal more about the guy you want to get involved with.